Back in the days of WW2, it was a highly risky manoeuvre to land at an enemies shore. Most famous example of course D-Day with (often overrated, but still) significant Allies casualties in spite of massive naval and air superiority.
Why is this not reflected in CoW? Wouldn't it be an easy change to give also other ground units than artillery a minor attack and defense value against naval targets?
Like, for example, if they had 0.1 attack and 0.2 defense against naval targets, 1 unit disembarking at a place with one defending ground unit would lose 0.3 * 4:30 hours = 1.2 HP (<=> 20%).
Would make the game more realistic (you would no longer merely chose planes, but a greater variety of units as coastal defense) and a lot more interesting as it opens new strategic decisions... would be more challenging to decide where to place your ground forces, since they would then have one further use.
I only see two more adaptions that should be done:
1.: Best if naval units (disembarking ground units or ships) could have the option to just retreat from such a battle back into open sea - of course not without suffering fire from the other side during embarking time.
2.: Since it might happen that destroyers become involved in such a battle at the coast, they should get a small defense value against land units (about 0.5 or 1.0).
Why is this not reflected in CoW? Wouldn't it be an easy change to give also other ground units than artillery a minor attack and defense value against naval targets?
Like, for example, if they had 0.1 attack and 0.2 defense against naval targets, 1 unit disembarking at a place with one defending ground unit would lose 0.3 * 4:30 hours = 1.2 HP (<=> 20%).
Would make the game more realistic (you would no longer merely chose planes, but a greater variety of units as coastal defense) and a lot more interesting as it opens new strategic decisions... would be more challenging to decide where to place your ground forces, since they would then have one further use.
I only see two more adaptions that should be done:
1.: Best if naval units (disembarking ground units or ships) could have the option to just retreat from such a battle back into open sea - of course not without suffering fire from the other side during embarking time.
2.: Since it might happen that destroyers become involved in such a battle at the coast, they should get a small defense value against land units (about 0.5 or 1.0).
The post was edited 1 time, last by Hans A. Pils: Closed the poll, since Vorlon is right - no change in the mechanics needed. ().